52 Brushy Neck Lane

A Masterpiece of Historic Charm and Modern Sophistication
South of Montauk. Over 6,500 square feet. One of a kind.
Step into timeless elegance at this showstopping 1875 Victorian estate, completely rebuilt in 2008 with no expense spared. Nestled on just over one acre of private, manicured grounds, this home offers more than 6,500 square feet of living space—not including a 2,000 square foot walk-out basement that’s ready for your vision.
From the moment you arrive, the exterior commands attention with cedar siding, hand-laid red brick chimneys, and detailed masonry. Inside, every detail has been curated for impact. Brazilian cherry hardwood floors with maple inlays. Five fireplaces. Hand-carved woodwork that tells a story in every room.
The kitchen is nothing short of exceptional. Outfitted with premium appliances, propane cooking, dual dishwashers, and a wood-burning stove that doubles as a pizza oven, it's built to entertain and built to last. The formal dining room, expansive living areas, and a private guest suite on the main level make hosting effortless.
Upstairs, the primary suite is a retreat unto itself—complete with a fireplace, private balcony, sitting area or office, and a spa-caliber bath featuring a steam shower. Three additional bedrooms and beautifully appointed bathrooms round out the second level.
For car collectors and hobbyists, the six-car garage with 9-foot doors and 13-foot ceilings offers room for everything—tools, toys, and dreams alike.
Outside, a heated gunite pool delivers resort-style living, while the 500-gallon propane tank keeps things running efficiently. And the 2,000-square-foot walk-out basement? With high ceilings, a fireplace, and separate access, it’s the perfect blank slate for a gym, home theater, or guest retreat.
With four-zone heating, central air, a 1,000-gallon oil tank, and oversized water main, comfort and performance are built into every square inch.
Located just minutes from top-rated schools, shopping, parks, and major transportation, this home offers more than luxury—it offers a legacy. Whether you're hosting on a grand scale or carving out your own private sanctuary, this is a rare opportunity to own a historic estate completely reimagined for modern living.