Back

About Water Mill, NY

City Guide

About Water Mill

Real Estate & Housing

Neighborhoods

Lifestyle in Water Mill

Schools & Education

Getting Around

Parks & Recreation

MARKET SNAPSHOT

The Market at a Glance

How homes have been selling here over the last 90 days.

home_work New This Week 1
Went Under Contract 0
trending_down Price Reductions 0
payments Median Sale Price $4,100,000 —
square_foot Price per Sq Ft $943
schedule Avg Days on Market 83
sell Homes Sold 1
percent Sale-to-List Ratio 91.0%
inventory_2 Months of Inventory 68.0

Price & Sales History

Market data reflects closed sales over the last 90 days and is provided for informational purposes.

For sale

Houses in Water Mill, NY

Handpicked properties hitting the scene in your area.

19 Joan Road For Sale
$949,990
19 Joan RoadBay Shore, NY 11706
  • 4 bd
  • 5 ba
  • 2840 sqft
  • Built 1966
  • 1017682
57-68 Mazeau Street For Sale
$699,000
57-68 Mazeau StreetMaspeth, NY 11378
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1853 sqft
  • Built 1930
  • 1024045
29 Boxwood Drive For Sale
$799,000
29 Boxwood DriveKings Park, NY 11754
  • 4 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1836 sqft
  • Built 1966
  • KEY1040806
249 Cold Spring Road For Sale
$1,848,000
249 Cold Spring RoadSyosset, NY 11791
  • 5 bd
  • 4 ba
  • 3555 sqft
  • Built 1951
  • 1006505
269 Suffolk Avenue For Sale
$799,000
269 Suffolk AvenueMassapequa, NY 11758
  • 4 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1436 sqft
  • Built 1954
  • 1039575
560 Little Noyac Path For Sale
$9,950,000
560 Little Noyac PathWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 8 bd
  • 9.5 ba
  • 9857 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • 1039305
Coming Soon
$585,000
361 Decatur AvenueShirley, NY 11967
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1140 sqft
  • Built 1975
  • KEY1042139
85-12 65th Drive For Sale
$999,000
85-12 65th DriveRego Park, NY 11374
  • 3 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 1940 sqft
  • Built 1938
  • 977829
728 Martin Drive For Sale
$719,000
728 Martin DriveUniondale, NY 11553
  • 4 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 1600 sqft
  • Built 1949
  • 995676
312 Peconic Avenue For Sale
$699,000
312 Peconic AvenueMedford, NY 11763
  • 5 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 1120 sqft
  • Built 1997
  • 1022296
28 Cammerer Avenue For Sale
$649,999
28 Cammerer AvenueEast Rockaway, NY 11518
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1235 sqft
  • Built 1928
  • 1023374
17 E Lincoln Avenue For Sale
$869,000
17 E Lincoln AvenueMassapequa, NY 11758
  • 4 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 2552 sqft
  • Built 1988
  • 1033212

For sale

Townhomes in Water Mill, NY

Handpicked properties hitting the scene in your area.

744 Main Street #1 For Rent
$3,500
744 Main Street #1Greenport, NY 11944
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2600 sqft
  • Built 1820
  • 1007625
5 Bush Avenue #2 For Rent
$3,500
5 Bush Avenue #2Port Chester, NY 10573
  • 4 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1191 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • KEY1040468
6 Ticonderoga Court For Rent
$2,750
6 Ticonderoga CourtRidge, NY 11961
  • 2 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1000 sqft
  • Built 1972
  • KEY1041914
9001 70th Drive For Rent
$2,950
9001 70th DriveForest Hills, NY 11375
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 900 sqft
  • Built 1945
  • KEY1041273
229 S Ridge Street ##B For Rent
$4,500
229 S Ridge Street ##BRye Brook, NY 10573
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1700 sqft
  • Built 1920
  • KEY1041632
398 Bauer Place For Rent
$4,500
398 Bauer PlaceMineola, NY 11501
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1475 sqft
  • Built 1931
  • 1036389
Address Not Shown For Rent
$1,500
Address Not ShownJamaica, NY 11433
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2380 sqft
  • Built 1925
  • KEY1040967
69-68 229th Street ##1 For Rent
$5,800
69-68 229th Street ##1Bayside, NY 11364
  • 3 bd
  • 3.5 ba
  • 2100 sqft
  • Built 2013
  • KEY1041714
275 Central Avenue #1 For Rent
$4,800
275 Central Avenue #1Lawrence, NY 11559
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • Built 2003
  • KEY1041480
245 Beach Breeze Lane For Rent
$3,600
245 Beach Breeze LaneArverne, NY 11692
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2100 sqft
  • Built 2004
  • KEY1041539
6 Maple Avenue #1 For Rent
$2,600
6 Maple Avenue #1Goshen, NY 10924
  • 2 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1155 sqft
  • Built 1986
  • KEY1041100
54 Farquhar Avenue #1 For Rent
$3,800
54 Farquhar Avenue #1Yonkers, NY 10701
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1700 sqft
  • Built 1964
  • KEY1040063

For sale

Condos in Water Mill, NY

Handpicked properties hitting the scene in your area.

400 Noyack Road #E2 For Sale
$1,325,000
400 Noyack Road #E2Southampton, NY 11968
  • 2 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1640 sqft
  • Built 1986
  • 1040167
1205 E Broadway #F-24 Active
$250,000
1205 E Broadway #F-24Hewlett, NY 11557
  • 2 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 17948 sqft
  • Built 1925
  • 1031861
2453 Union #20B Active
$239,999
2453 Union #20BIslip, NY 11751
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 940 sqft
  • Built 1970
  • KEY1041518
62-54 97th Place #PHC For Sale
$899,000
62-54 97th Place #PHCRego Park, NY 11374
  • 2 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1004 sqft
  • Built 1987
  • 967308
20 Bush Avenue Coming Soon
$339,000
20 Bush AvenueNewburgh, NY 12550
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1185 sqft
  • Built 1918
  • KEY1042135
185 Battery Avenue #2A For Sale
$1,199,000
185 Battery Avenue #2ABrooklyn, NY 11209
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1400 sqft
  • Built 2010
  • 1029779
1870 Baldwin Road #79 For Rent
$4,150
1870 Baldwin Road #79Yorktown Heights, NY 10598
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1074 sqft
  • Built 2002
  • KEY1041033
342 E 194th Street For Rent
$3,400
342 E 194th StreetBronx, NY 10458
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 2466 sqft
  • Built 1910
  • KEY1042158
505 White Plains Road #4H Coming Soon
$2,995
505 White Plains Road #4HEastchester, NY 10709
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 900 sqft
  • Built 1978
  • KEY1042151
2 Park Avenue #3H For Rent
$2,700
2 Park Avenue #3HEastchester, NY 10709
  • 1 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 550 sqft
  • Built 1976
  • KEY1042149
97-31 92nd Street For Rent
$3,000
97-31 92nd StreetOzone Park, NY 11416
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 900 sqft
  • Built 1920
  • KEY1042141
5 Secora #F2 Coming Soon
$169,000
5 Secora #F2Monsey, NY 10952
  • 1 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 820 sqft
  • Built 1976
  • KEY1042075

Zip Codes

BROWSE BY ZIP

Browse listings by postal code in this area.

068072 homes for saleMedian sale$1.3MPer sq ft$629 sales in the last 90 days
068111 home for saleMedian sale$490KPer sq ft$6247 sales in the last 90 days
068122 homes for saleMedian sale$600KPer sq ft$633 sales in the last 90 days
068308 homes for saleMedian sale$1.2MPer sq ft$6733 sales in the last 90 days
068312 homes for saleMedian sale$1.9MPer sq ft$2920 sales in the last 90 days
069021 home for saleMedian sale$310KPer sq ft$62118 sales in the last 90 days
069034 homes for saleMedian sale$1.3MPer sq ft$539 sales in the last 90 days
074501 home for saleMedian sale$760KPer sq ft$4921 sale in the last 90 days
076771 home for saleMedian sale$1.3MPer sq ft$62
078271 home for saleMedian sale$190KPer sq ft$1091 sale in the last 90 days
086111 home for saleMedian sale$203KPer sq ft$85413 sales in the last 90 days
088161 home for saleMedian sale$570KPer sq ft$30568 sales in the last 90 days
View All Zip Codes
Get Alerts Advanced Search
  • Map
  • List
14 Rose Hill Road For Rent
$200,000
14 Rose Hill RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 4 ba
  • 3100 sqft
  • Built 1989
  • 1040052
560 Little Noyac Path For Sale
$9,950,000
560 Little Noyac PathWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 8 bd
  • 9.5 ba
  • 9857 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • 1039305
4 Trail Court For Sale
$3,350,000
4 Trail CourtWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 4.5 ba
  • 1720 sqft
  • Built 1994
  • 1036793
165 Strongs Lane For Sale
$7,995,000
165 Strongs LaneWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 7 bd
  • 8.5 ba
  • 8200 sqft
  • Built 2027
  • 1034727
15 Little Cobb Road For Sale
$8,500,000
15 Little Cobb RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 3059 sqft
  • Built 1910
  • 1034186
652 Noyack Path For Sale
$5,499,000
652 Noyack PathWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 6 bd
  • 6 ba
  • 5209 sqft
  • Built 2005
  • 1029122
1477 Deerfield Road For Rent
$155,000
1477 Deerfield RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 6 bd
  • 8 ba
  • 7500 sqft
  • Built 2017
  • 912676
203 Head Of Pond Road For Sale
$1,998,999
203 Head Of Pond RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 3 bd
  • 3.5 ba
  • 1970 sqft
  • Built 1996
  • 1019753
104 Osprey Way For Sale
$8,495,000
104 Osprey WayWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 5.5 ba
  • 3702 sqft
  • Built 2017
  • 1018047
61 Lower 7 Ponds Road For Sale
$4,095,000
61 Lower 7 Ponds RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 4 ba
  • Built 1898
  • L3586103
1999 Deerfield Road For Sale
$3,800,000
1999 Deerfield RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 5 bd
  • 4.5 ba
  • 4108 sqft
  • Built 2003
  • 1012206
172 Mill Pond Lane For Sale
$3,195,000
172 Mill Pond LaneWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 4.5 ba
  • 3500 sqft
  • Built 1998
  • 958968
672 Halsey Lane For Sale
$24,995,000
672 Halsey LaneWater Mill, NY 11932
  • 9 bd
  • 12 ba
  • 15000 sqft
  • Built 2009
  • 998314
460 Edge Of Woods Road For Sale
$15,995,000
460 Edge Of Woods RoadWater Mill, NY 11968
  • 8 bd
  • 11 ba
  • 9906 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • 991792
450 Seven Ponds Towd Road For Sale
$11,995,000
450 Seven Ponds Towd RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 8 bd
  • 11 ba
  • 9906 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • 986783
532 Blank Lane For Sale
$4,895,000
532 Blank LaneWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 4.5 ba
  • 3500 sqft
  • Built 2013
  • 987428
14 Old Trail Road For Rent
$35,000
14 Old Trail RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 2040 sqft
  • Built 2001
  • 986487
54 Hayground Road For Sale
$1,995,000
54 Hayground RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2400 sqft
  • Built 1961
  • 971595
316 Deerfield Road For Rent
$200,000
316 Deerfield RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 6 bd
  • 8 ba
  • 8000 sqft
  • Built 2016
  • 969578
2 Strongs Lane For Sale
$3,749,500
2 Strongs LaneWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 3 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 2800 sqft
  • Built 1920
  • 916216
1366 Scuttle Hole Road For Sale
$5,495,000
1366 Scuttle Hole RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 5 bd
  • 5.5 ba
  • 4631 sqft
  • Built 2012
  • 961068
1552 Deerfield Road For Sale
$9,995,000
1552 Deerfield RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 8 bd
  • 11 ba
  • 9400 sqft
  • Built 2025
  • 950327
112 Upper 7 Ponds Road For Sale
$2,295,000
112 Upper 7 Ponds RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 4 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 2134 sqft
  • Built 1993
  • 941317
158 Cobb Road For Sale
$10,500,000
158 Cobb RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 7 bd
  • 7.5 ba
  • 9600 sqft
  • Built 2025
  • 937172
26 Georgian Lane For Rent
$135,000
26 Georgian LaneWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 6 bd
  • 6.5 ba
  • 5400 sqft
  • Built 2023
  • 910850
29 Wood Edge Court For Rent
$225,000
29 Wood Edge CourtWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 7 bd
  • 7 ba
  • 6461 sqft
  • Built 2017
  • 896996
322 Rose Hill Road For Sale
$10,250,000
322 Rose Hill RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 5 bd
  • 4.5 ba
  • 4110 sqft
  • Built 2000
  • 847331
700 Edge Of Woods Road For Sale
$2,995,000
700 Edge Of Woods RoadWater Mill, NY 11976
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1700 sqft
  • Built 1979
  • L3586117

Nearby Cities

All Cities

Similar Searches

Featured Areas

All Areas

Featured Searches

Advanced Search

Popular Cities

All Cities

Popular Subdivisions

All Subdivisions

Popular Zip Codes

All Zips

Recent Articles

All Articles
Contact us

Keller Williams Landmark

(718) 749-9192

vinny@askvinnythompson.com

75-35 31st Avenue, STE 202 Jackson Heights, NY 11370

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.